Broiler-Safe 13 by 9-Inch Baking Dishes

From Cook's Country | October/November 2010

Overview:

Since our favorite 13 by 9-inch Pyrex dish can’t go under the broiler, we looked for one that could.

When it comes to casseroles, our favorite pan is the Pyrex Bakeware 9x13 Baking Dish. At just $8.99, this inexpensive workhorse is perfect—OK, almost perfect. Pyrex does not recommend that its oven-safe tempered glassware go under the broiler; abrupt temperature changes can cause it to crack or shatter, a condition called thermal shock. We needed an alternative with roughly the same dimensions and capacity, since many recipes are sized to fit the Pyrex, but one that could handle the heat. We gathered seven rectangular broiler-safe baking dishes, priced between $37 and $125, and cranked up the heat.

Broiler-safe baking dishes are usually made of enameled cast iron or ceramic—materials that are manufactured at temperatures far exceeding the average home broiler. We tested two enameled cast-iron dishes and five ceramic dishes, including two of porcelain, which is lighter, harder, and less porous than many other ceramics. To… read more

Since our favorite 13 by 9-inch Pyrex dish can’t go under the broiler, we looked for one that could.

When it comes to casseroles, our favorite pan is the Pyrex Bakeware 9x13 Baking Dish. At just $8.99, this inexpensive workhorse is perfect—OK, almost perfect. Pyrex does not recommend that its oven-safe tempered glassware go under the broiler; abrupt temperature changes can cause it to crack or shatter, a condition called thermal shock. We needed an alternative with roughly the same dimensions and capacity, since many recipes are sized to fit the Pyrex, but one that could handle the heat. We gathered seven rectangular broiler-safe baking dishes, priced between $37 and $125, and cranked up the heat.

Broiler-safe baking dishes are usually made of enameled cast iron or ceramic—materials that are manufactured at temperatures far exceeding the average home broiler. We tested two enameled cast-iron dishes and five ceramic dishes, including two of porcelain, which is lighter, harder, and less porous than many other ceramics. To determine whether these dishes could withstand both prolonged exposure to high heat as well as thermal shock, we prepared Boston Baked Scrod, a dish that cooks entirely under the broiler, and Chantilly Potatoes, a recipe we finish under the broiler.

While all contenders emerged intact from the blasting heat, testing revealed a secondary problem: weight. The enameled cast-iron dishes were a challenge to maneuver, weighing 6.7 pounds and 10.5 pounds empty. Filled with several more pounds of hot Chantilly Potatoes, these dishes were tough to remove from the oven without spilling molten cream and cheese. Ordinary ceramic dishes were a little better, weighing between 4.25 and 5.1 pounds. But we preferred the lightweight porcelain dishes, averaging 3.8 pounds, which were easy to carry even when full.

Because heat comes from above during broiling, the pan’s conductivity has less effect on its cooking performance than it would if used in baking. So it came as no surprise that few differences emerged in the way fish broiled or cheese, cream, and potatoes browned in each baking dish. Instead, design and shape factored largest in a dish’s success. Oversized, shallow dishes offered so much surface area that potatoes spread too thinly, and too much liquid evaporated from the scrod. Smaller, deeper dishes left plenty of juices in the scrod, but tapering sides on one reduced its capacity, causing it to nearly overflow with Chantilly Potatoes. Dishes with flared or scalloped edges were difficult to get into with a spatula for serving.

The single most important factor, however, was the length and width of the handles. All but one of the dishes we tested had handles, though several were too small to grasp securely while wearing oven mitts. It hardly needs saying that a safe, secure grip is essential when you’re carrying a red-hot baking dish.

In the end, we preferred baking dishes that were lightweight, with large, easy-to-grip handles and straight sides, and we hoped not to have to spend too much. Sure, we’ll keep using our basic, inexpensive Pyrex, but when it’s time to turn up the heat, we’ve got a new favorite. At $37.49, our winning baking dish has it all.

less
  • Product Tested

    Results Key:

    Good ★ ★ ★ Fair ★ ★ Poor
  • Prices are subject to change.
  • Highly Recommended - Winner

    HIC Porcelain Lasagna Baking Dish

    This porcelain baking dish has large handles for secure gripping and straight sides for easy serving. It’s deep enough for Chantilly Potatoes, but not so large that the butter burned as we broiled scrod. Finally, it was not too heavy, even filled with potatoes.

    • Design ★★★
    • Cooking ★★★

    $37.49

    BUY NOW Amazon
  • Recommended

    Emile Henry Lasagna Dish

    Chantilly Potatoes and scrod broiled perfectly in this well-proportioned pan. The dish was easy to transport as well as to clean (although we would have preferred larger handles), and the food came out cleanly from the straight sides.

    • Design ★★
    • Cooking ★★★

    $66.00

  • Recommended with Reservations

    Le Creuset Small Roaster

    Small but hefty, this dish cooked everything evenly and managed to contain the full batch of Chantilly Potatoes. But the combination of narrow handles and cast-iron weight made it difficult to safely slide out from under the broiler.

    • Design ★★
    • Cooking ★★

    $124.95

  • Recommended with Reservations

    Pillivuyt Large Rectangular Baker

    Small and lightweight, this porcelain dish had thin walls and shallow sides. It was easy to carry and cooked food beautifully. But its curled handles were too small to grip properly with oven mitts—our thumbs often ended up in the food.

    • Design ★★
    • Cooking ★★

    $56.95

  • Not Recommended

    Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Enameled Cast Iron 14-inch Roasting/Lasagna Pan

    This enameled cast-iron baking dish was the biggest and heftiest of the bunch. Lifting it when it was filled with Chantilly Potatoes was a chore. It was just too unwieldy. Also, although the pan cooked well, the food was too spread out, so we had to pull it out of the oven earlier than expected.

    • Design
    • Cooking ★★

    $59.95

  • Not Recommended

    Esprit de Cuisine By Appolia Baking Dish

    The angled-in sides pinched capacity, so the dish was cramped and overfilled with a batch of potatoes. While the dimensions around the top rim were similar to other dishes’, the bottom of the dish measured only 10¼ by 5½ inches. The wavy edge looked nice but made serving difficult.

    • Design
    • Cooking ★★

    $60.00

  • Not Recommended

    Piral Rectangular Baking Dish

    While food emerged cooked as desired, this dish had no handles, so getting it in and out of the oven was an adventure. Made from terra cotta, it needed to be soaked in water for 6 to 8 hours before its first use. And after just one use, the bottom of the dish appeared bowed.

    • Design
    • Cooking ★★

    $54.95

In My Favorites
Please Wait…
Remove Favorite
Add to custom collection