Boiled shrimp often turn out rubbery and bland. Don’t let that happen to yours.
Why This Recipe Works
Shrimp Cocktail is a classic at parties, but it rarely does justice to the festive occasion: The shrimp are overcooked, rubbery, and flavorless, and they’re served with a sugary-sweet cocktail sauce. To ensure perfectly cooked shrimp, we start them in cool water, bring it up to a simmer, and then immediately kill the heat and cover the pot. When the shrimp are pink and tender, we add ice to stop the cooking process. Finally, we developed a traditional cocktail sauce—ketchup and horseradish based—that’s balanced enough to complement the sweet shrimp instead of hiding their flavor.