Are special dispensers for plastic wrap really worth buying? We found one that definitely is.
How We Tested
Store-bought boxes of plastic wrap feature teeth or slide cutters that require the user to keep one hand on the box while attempting to pull and cut tangle-free sheets with the other hand. This can cause ragged cuts and leave the plastic wrap sticking to itself, leading to headaches and waste.
Plastic-wrap dispensers promise to remedy these issues. These products, typically made of plastic or thick cardboard and able to accommodate a variety of roll sizes, all have built-in cutters—either a slide cutter or a push-down blade. They are designed to remain stationary on the counter, freeing up both of the user’s hands to evenly pull and cut tangle-free sheets. To find out if these dispensers were worth using, we purchased three models priced from $11.95 to $23.38 and put them to the test.
We were pleasantly surprised that most of the dispensers were a dramatic improvement on the built-in dispenser that came with our winning plastic wrap, Glad Cling Wrap Clear Plastic. But it wasn’t all smooth sailing. The ChicWrap Plastic Wrap Dispenser’s slide-cutter knob occasionally got buried under the plastic wrap, forcing us to reposition the plastic wrap before cutting. And this cardboard model was so light that pulling out the plastic wrap shifted the entire dispenser. The only way to avoid this was to awkwardly pull upward and then out before cutting.
But one model fared even worse. The Kuhn Rikon Fast Wrap Flatware Organizer also shifted on the counter when we pulled wrap forward, so again we had to pull up first and then forward. But more problematic was the Kuhn Rikon’s push-down cutting mechanism, which sometimes gave us perforated plastic wrap instead of a clean cut. This product performed better after we shifted our hand placement from the outer edges of the dispenser to the center of the dispenser when we pressed down to cut, though even then it occasionally still didn’t cut cleanly. This dispenser also made a loud croaking noise when we pulled plastic wrap, which didn’t hinder the dispenser’s performance but was certainly bothersome.
The star of the show was the Stretch-Tite Wrap’n Snap 7500 Dispenser ($22.00), which performed the best in every test. Its cleverly concealed blade gave us a clean cut every time, the loading mechanism was smooth and tangle-free, we could pull plastic wrap forward without the dispenser falling over, and its height—it stands tallest of the bunch—made it easier to wrap bowls. In sum, it was easier and faster to use than the box of wrap you buy at the supermarket.
The only catch? The Stretch-Tite dispenser can’t be stored in shallow kitchen drawers, as it stands almost 5 inches high. But it’s a minor price to pay for effortlessly smooth sheets of plastic wrap.
We tested three plastic-wrap dispensers priced from $11.95 to $23.38, equipping each dispenser with a full roll of Glad Cling Wrap Clear Plastic, our winning plastic wrap. To test ease of use, cutting ability, and tangle avoidance, we repeatedly pulled 12-inch and 6-inch sheets of plastic wrap from each dispenser. We also repeatedly wrapped a glass bowl—both empty and after being heated in the microwave with 1/2 cup of water in it. We tested stability by noting whether the dispenser moved from its spot on the counter when we pulled sheets of plastic wrap, and we tested speed by timing 15 pulls—five 12-inch sheets, five 6-inch sheets, and wrapping a glass bowl filled with heated water five times—and averaging the times. We tested the blade durability on the winning dispenser by pulling 100 sheets of plastic wrap in a row, and we tested ease of storage by attempting to place each dispenser in two different shallow kitchen drawers. All models were purchased online and appear in order of preference.
Stability: We rated each dispenser on whether it remained stationary on the counter while we were pulling plastic wrap, giving top preference to models that did not move during use or require extra finagling.
Tangle Avoidance: We pulled 6-inch and 12-inch sheets of plastic wrap, and we pulled sheets big enough to cover a bowl—both empty at room temperature and after being heated in the microwave with 1/2 cup of water in it—assigning more points to models that consistenty dispensed tangle-free sheets.
Cutting Ability: We pulled sheets of plastic wrap during multiple rounds of testing, noting how well the dispensers’ blades cut the plastic, and gave top ratings to dispensers that made consistently clean cuts.
Ease of Use: We prepared dispensers for use, installed rolls of plastic wrap, pulled sheets of plastic wrap in varying sizes, and pulled sheets to be used to cover a bowl, giving highest marks to dispensers that were easy to set up, remained stationary during use, and allowed us to easily pull sheets of plastic wrap.