Black and White Cookies

44 comments

Appears in Cook's Country February/March 2012, Cook's Country TV

These huge, tender cookies may be New York’s best-kept secret. We spill it.

SERVES Makes 12 cookies

TIME 1 hour, plus 2¼ hours cooling

has video

WHY THIS RECIPE WORKS

This enormous New York City deli favorite begins with a cakelike “cookie” bottom. Our glaze needed milk for flavor but required the addition of just enough corn syrup to make it thick enough to rest on top of the cookies instead of sinking ...

Print