America's Test Kitchen LogoCook's Country LogoCook's Illustrated Logo

Common Pie Dough Mistakes (and How to Avoid Them)

The thousands of pies we've baked over the years in the test kitchen have taught us a thing or three about what can go wrong when rolling the dough.

The thousands of pies we've baked over the years in the test kitchen have taught us a thing or three about what can go wrong when rolling the dough.

Here are the three most common problems—and instructions for avoiding them.

UNEVEN, ASYMMETRICAL PIE "ROUND"

CAUSE:

Poor rolling technique, or dough too cold to roll

SOLUTION:

Roll, rotate, repeat and let the dough warm up if necessary

TORN DOUGH

CAUSE:

Manhandling en route

SOLUTION:

Use rolling pin to transfer dough to pie plate

SHRUNKEN BAKED SHELL

CAUSE:

Stretched or insufficiently chilled dough

SOLUTION:

Support dough when fitting, and chill before baking

Recommended Reading

This is a members' feature.